Skip to Main Content

Geography and Geology: Evaluating Your Sources?

Geography and Geology

Evaluating Sources Critically

Authority

Who is the author?

Is he/she an expert in the field?

What is his/her credentials?

What are his/her institutional and professional affiliations?

Who is the publisher?

 Are they known for scholarly publications?

 Objectivity

 Are the goals of the work clearly stated?

Are authoritative sources cited?

Are arguments and conclusions supported by evidence?

 Accuracy

Are sources for factual information clearly stated and can be verified?

Is the information free of grammatical, spelling, or typographical errors?

Is the information peer-reviewed?

Is the author's methodology presented?

 Reliability and Credibility

Is the information valid and well-researched?

Is the information presented still valid and applicable today?

Does the information have a complete list of references from authoritative sources?

Are quotes and other strong assertions supported by sources that can be easily located?

Currency

Is the information up to date?

When was the information published?

Has it been updated since the first publication?

If it's information on the web, do links work?

 

Source Evaluation

There is a proliferation of information especially on the World Wide Web. As such, users must be able to evaluate these resources to ascertain suitable information for their research needs. The video below provides a guide on how to evaluate information resources.

Plagiarism Checkers and Detectors

Turnitin

Turnitin is an Internet-based plagiarism prevention service created by iParadigms, LLC. Usually, universities including the UWI subscribe to the software which enables students to run papers to the Turnitin website, which checks the documents for unoriginal content.

PaperRater

PaperRater.com is a free resource, developed and maintained by linguistics professionals and graduate students. It is used by schools and universities in over 46 countries to help students improve their writing by checking for plagiarism. 

Plagium

Plagium is a free online multilingual plagiarism tracker that allows you to check whether content from your website or research paper has been copied and used anywhere else.

Dupli Checker

It is a free plagiarism detection software that helps in improving the originality of your content from plagiarism and making it original. Each sentence is dissected, and all the source websites from where the content was copied are displayed.

Small SEO Tools

Check your papers for plagiarism but is limited to 1500 words per search.

Scholarly versus Popular Sources

Purdue Owl